Review of Unleashing Nepal By Sujeev Shakya
Unleashing Nepal by Sujeev Shakya provides a comprehensive
explanation of different governments’ economic stances on the economics of
Nepal at their respective times, and how different facets of Nepali society
have led us to where we are. Through his interesting observations (like how
kings believed development was not a necessity but their grace toward their
subjects, and how a similar attitude has been passed down to bilateral donors) we
can begin to understand various present situations, from simple delays in
projects involving international parties to our geopolitical image.
Although Shakya’s book has a bright cover, most
chapters explore the rather grim reality of Nepali society and its economic
conditions. Shakya claims to be ultra-optimistic in his book and presents us with
many great opportunities he believes Nepal is missing out on. Additionally,
considering that it was written more than five years ago, he seems to have hit
the mark on multiple sectors where Nepal is prospering, as well as on areas
where Nepal is still struggling five years down the line. However, most of the
prospects shown by Shakya remain just that—prospects. He does not explain how
to fundamentally tackle these problems, nor does he clearly identify what
exactly the problems in the systems are. I found the problems he identified to
be very generalized, similar to what one might write during SLC on how Nepal
could be improved—albeit with much more research and facts to support his
point.
Although the economic analysis of the past was
better than what I had expected, the lack of constructive feedback and the
reliance on general ideas about what could be developed made it feel similar to
a politician’s speech: a bit visionary rather than truly analytical, leaving me
somewhat disappointed. Additionally, some data inconsistencies (such as the
Maoist insurgency having different death tolls in different chapters) left me a
bit confused.
However, the new perspective it brings makes it a satisfying read at the end of the day.
Comments
Post a Comment